Flow Measurement Questions : Preparing for Field Instrumentation Interview then read this article about flow measurement and test yourself.
Flow Measurement Questions & Answers
What are the reference conditions for measuring volume flow rate?
There are two different reference conditions.
One is N.T.P. and other is called S.T.P.
Normal condition of Temperature and Pressure is NTP.
Standard condition of Temperature and Pressure is STP.
The definitions for these conditions are defined but are interchanging in various countries. In India they are defined as follows,
NTP: 0° C Temperature and 1 Atmosphere Pressure.
STP: 15° C Temperature and 1 Atmosphere Pressure.
Why accuracy gets hampered with variation of temperature and pressure?
As explained in question 2 above the volume of fluid changes with change in temperature and pressure.
If we are measuring volumetric flow naturally we will find different readings of flow rate at different pressure and temperature for the same quantity of flow.
If we are measuring Mass flow rate, the density changes with change in temperature and pressure.
so the flow rate readings will not be accurate (refer to the expression of mass flow rate in question 1 above.
How to avoid effects of temperature and pressure variations while measuring flow rate of compressible fluid? What is density compensation?
To avoid the effects of variation of temperature and pressure on flow measurement the flowing pressure and flowing temperature is measured.
From this data the density is computed and as per the expression given in question 1 above for mass flow rate the value for the same is calculated. Pressure Temperature compensation and Density compensation is one and the same.
For calculating volumetric flow rate first the mass flow rate is calculated and then it is divided by density at NTP or STP conditions as per requirement.
This type of correction is also known as density compensation.
What is the typical accuracy of this type of systems using orifice as primary element?
There are two standards that govern the flow measuring system using orifice or other restriction elements.
BS 1042
ISO 5167.
As per these standards the maximum error of measurement is within ±3%.
Carefully crafting of the primary element and other components can reduce the error down to 1½ % to 2%.
What is meant by Beta Ratio? What is its normal range?
Beta (ß) Ratio is the ratio of orifice diameter to pipe internal diameter. Its normal range is from 0.4 to 0.8.
What are the piping requirements in terms of minimum upstream and downstream straight lengths near the orifice element?
The requirement of minimum straight lengths depends on two factors,
The Beta ratio : The more the beta ratio the more is the requirement of straight lengths, especially more on upstream side.
The type of disturbance on upstream side, e.g. One elbow in single plane, two elbows in one plane, two elbows in different planes, reducer or expander, regulator or valve operation.
It is difficult to tell any thumb rule for straight lengths but knowing the specific case proper straight lengths required on upstream and downstream side can be advised.
Requirement of upstream straight length varies between 7D and 24D. The variation of downstream is comparatively much less and varies between 3 to 5 times the internal diameters of pipe (D).
What does turndown ratio mean?
Turndown ratio is also commonly referred to as rangeability. It indicates the range in which a flow meter or controller can accurately measure the fluid.
In other words, it’s simply the high end of a measurement range compared to the low end, expressed in a ratio and is calculated using a simple formula.
Turndown Ratio = Maximum flow / Minimum flow
For example, if a given flow meter has a 50:1 turndown ratio the flow meter is capable of accurately measuring down to 1/50thof the maximum flow. So, suppose a flow meter has a full scale rating of 20 l/min the flow meter will measure down to 0.4 l/min of flow.
Keep in mind that the maximum and minimum flow capability of a meter or controller is likely to be a greater span than the measurable and controllable range.
For example, a mass flow controller with a 50:1 turndown ratio may have the capability of measuring as high as 25 ln/min or as low as 0.16 ln/min but the turndown ratio will govern the actual measurable range.
In this example if the calibrated high flow is 25 ln/min, then the lowest that can be measured is 0.5 ln/min (1/50th of 25). If the application requires that the calibrated minimum flow is 0.1 ln/min, then the maximum flow that can be measured is 5 ln/min (50 times 0.1).
A mental image of this concept may be to picture a set of 100 stairs (the overall minimum and maximum flow of an MFC), and a length of carpet that will only cover 50 stairs (turndown ratio).
You can cover (measure) any 50 of the 100 stairs, but you can not stretch the carpet to cover more than 50.
What are the advantages of a using a differential flowmeter?
can handle low flow gases and liquids
has an output signal for totalizing
switch selectable for different gases
What are the limitations of using a differential flowmeter?
for use with clean liquids only
maximum liquid viscosity of 5 cps
What are the advantages of using a mass flowmeter?
measure mass directly
can handle applications whose stream temperature and line pressures fluctuate.
What are the limitations of using a mass flowmeter?
calibrated to a specific gas type
Doppler Flowmeters Questions & Answers
How does a doppler flowmeter work?
A high frequency signal is projected through the wall of the pipe and into the liquid. The signal is reflected off impurities in the liquid such as air bubbles or particles and sent back to the receiver.
The frequency difference between the transmitted and received signal is directly proportional to the fluid’s flow velocity.
Shall we use a doppler flowmeter with particulates?
Yes. In order to use a doppler flowmeter the liquid must have particulates or bubbles.
Most require a minimum size of 25 ppm or 30 μm; check with each doppler flowmeter for specific particle size requirements.
Some flowmeters measure in velocity (ft/sec). How can I convert the readings to volume/time?
GPM= 2.45 * (ID in inches)² * (VELOCITY in ft/sec)
GPM= gallons per minute
ID = inside diameter of the pipe in inches.
This formula is for waterit does not consider viscosity temperature or pressure.
However temperature viscosity and pressure will not effect a doppler flow reading.
What if my fluid is not water?
The speed of sound through water is approximately 1470 ft/sec.
Most instruments are calibrated for that rate.
Other fluids may be used but your instrument should then be recalibrated.
Will pipe insulation/thickness affect my reading?
Yes. Insulation should be removed before mounting the sensor.
Must a doppler flowmeter be permanently installed?
No. Because doppler flowmeters measure flow externally most can be easily removed also.
Does a doppler flowmeter require a minimum upstream straight pipe length?
Yes. Doppler flowmeters require ten pipe diameters from any valve tee bend etc.
Doppler flowmeters also require a full pipe flow.
What are the advantages of using a doppler flowmeter?
non-invasive
good for slurries aerated liquids
portable
What are the limitations of using a doppler flowmeter?
not suitable for clean liquids
requires straight upstream piping
Paddle Wheel Flowmeters Questions & Answers
How does a paddle-wheel flowmeter work?
Magnets are installed on each paddle of the sensor which is inserted into the liquid.
As the paddle turns an electrical frequency output proportional to the flow velocity is generated.
What is the “K” factor when used with insertion-type paddle wheel meters ?
The “K” factor is used to properly process the pulses from the flow sensor to the monitor device. It is the number of pulses the sensor sends per unit of fluid passing through the pipe.
The number is different for each pipe size and pipe material the sensor is used with. These numbers are determined through extensive testing by each meter manufacturer.
What if my liquid is foamy or turbulent?
Because these sensors use laminar flow characteristics foamy or turbulent liquids will not be read accurately. The sensors must also be installed in a full flowing straight section of pipe.
How long of a straight section of pipe do we need?
For systems with no bends or restrictions allow a minimum of 15 pipe diameters upstream and 5 pipe diameters downstream.
What do we need for a paddle-wheel system?
a. flow sensor
b. pipe fitting
c. meter or controller to read the signals from the sensor and indicate them in GPM or LPM
My flow meter reads in GPMthe flow sensors are in ft/sec. How do we know which one is appropriate for my flow?
To convert from velocity to flow use:
GPM= ft/sec x (ID)2 x 2.45
GPM= gallons per minute
ID = inside diameter of the pipe
This formula is for waterit does not consider viscosity temperature or pressure.
What do we need to know about my system when ordering a new flow meter?
In order to correctly calibrate your flowmeter we need to know:
Type of fluid
Expected flow rate
Max. fluid temp and system pressure
% suspended particles by volume
Pipe size (ID) material and wall thickness (schedule).
What are the advantages of using a paddle-wheel flowmeter?
good repeatability
low pressure drop
easy maintenance
What are the limitations of using a paddle-wheel flowmeter?
minimum upstream/downstream piping requirements
full pipe require.
Turbine Flowmeters Questions & Answers
How does a turbine flowmeter work?
As liquid or gas flows through the turbine it turns an impeller blade that is sensed by infrared beams photo-electric sensors or magnets.
An electrical pulse is then generated and converted to a frequency output proportional to the flow rate.
Can we use a turbine flowmeter with small particles?
No. Turbine flowmeters are best used with clean low-viscosity liquids.
Do we need a minimum straight distance before the sensor?
To maintain an even cross-sectional flow it is recommended that there be a straight pipe length of at least 10x the meter’s inner diameter upstream and at least 5x the meter’s inner diameter downstream of the sensor.
Check each flowmeter for specific requirements.
What if we have air in my liquid?
Some turbine flowmeters can be used with air. However if there are air bubbles or vapor pockets in the liquid the reading will be inaccurate.
There should be a laminar (stable) flow through the cross-section of the pipe.
What are the advantages of using a turbine flowmeter?
good accuracy with liquids
easy to install and maintain
signal output for totalizing
low flow rates available
What are the limitations of using a turbine flowmeter?
sensitive to viscosity changes
straight pipe line required
clean liquids and gases only
Variable Area Flowmeters Questions & Answers
How does a rotameter work?
Rotameters or variable area flowmeters operate on the principle that the variation in area of flow stream required to produce a constant pressure differential is proportional to the flow rate.
The flowing fluid enters the bottom of the meter passes upward through a metering tube and around the float exiting at the top.
The flow rate is read by noting the position of the float against the calibrated scale etched on the glass.
Where do we take the reading?
With the flowmeters the reading is taken at the center of the float.
It is recommended that the float be at eye level to minimize reading errors.
What is the difference between correlated and direct reading rotameters?
A direct reading flowmeter indicates the flow rate on its scale in specific engineering units (e.g. ml/min or scfh).
Direct reading scales are designed for a specific gas or liquid at a given temperature and pressure. While it is more convenient than a correlated flowmeter a direct reading flowmeter is less accurate and limited in its applications.
A correlated flowmeter is scaled along either a 65mm or a 150mm length from which a reading is taken. The reading is then compared to a correlation table for a specific gas or liquid.
This will give the actual flow in engineering units. One correlated flowmeter can be used with a variety of fluids or gases.
Can we use one flowmeter to measure different flow rates?
Yes. If a correlated flow tube is used different flow rates can be attained by using different floats i.e. carboloy, stainless steel, glass or sapphire.
Must a rotameter be mounted vertically?
Generally rotameters must be mounted vertically because the float must center itself in the fluid stream.
At high flow rates the float assumes a position towards the tip of the metering tube and at low flow rates positions itself lower in the tube.
Some of our rotameters have spring loaded floats and therefore may be mounted in any orientation.
What are the advantages of using a variable area flowmeter?
inexpensive
somewhat self-cleaning
no power required
available in different materials for chemical compatibility
What are the limitations of using a variable area flowmeter?
no output for data transmission
sensitive to differing gas types and changes in temperature and pressure
Practical Flow Measurement Questions & Answers
Can we use a rotameter in a vacuum application or with back pressure ?
Yes, but if you have a valve it must be placed at the outlet (top of the flowmeter). This is done by inverting the tube inside the frame and then turning over the frame.
At this position the tube should read correctly from the original perspective and the valve should be at the outlet or top of the flowmeter. This allows for proper control of the vacuum.
What are the advantages and disadvantages of an insertion-type flowmeter ?
Insertion meters typically have two parts: a flow sensor that is installed in the pipeline through a saddle, threaded inlet or special in-line fitting and the flow computer that displays the rate of flow and totalizes.
The advantages are many : Insertion meters are very cost effective relative to pipe size, especially in 4″ or larger pipes. This is because two sizes of insertion sensors can cover from 2″ to 48″ pipes. These meters are also very easy to install.
The flow sensors can be mounted in vertical or horizontal pipes and normally only require a 1-1/2″ or 2″ NPT female inlet to the pipe. A hot-tap version of a flow sensor allows installation on a pressurized line as well as easy service without depressurization.
Insertion meters also offer flexibility of use, since at any time a unit can be removed from one installation and reinstalled on another different size pipeline by simply reprogramming the flow computer.
The various flow computer/display/transmitters offer many features such as 4-20 mA output, scaleable pulse outputs, programmable relays and multiple inputs. Finally, these meters are easy to service – the flow sensor can usually be completely rebuilt in a few minutes without special tools.
The primary disadvantage is that insertion-type meters are not usually acceptable for billing purposes. Although these meters are very accurate, there is no AWWA standard and it is difficult to do precise testing and calibration as you would with a standard turbine meter that has test ports on it.
What kind of flowmeter will work for gravity flow, partially filled pipe applications?
An open channel flowmeter is the only truly reliable way to measure low velocity gravity flow discharges that are usually partially filled pipe applications.
The use of an open channel flowmeter (OCF) requires some type of primary measuring device such as a flume or weir. In such a device, the rate of flow is directly proportional to the level of the water moving through the flume or weir.
The OCF measures flow by being programmed to recognize the type and size of the flume or weir (usually done by simply selecting from a built-in menu) and then converting that level to a rate of flow.
How can we measure the effluent from my plant, which flows by gravity to a lagoon through a pipe that is not full?
There are two ways to measure gravity flows in partially full pipe. The most common is with an Open-Channel Flowmeter (OCF). This meter requires a primary measuring device such as a flume or weir.
The OCF is essentially a level device that calculates flows based on the characteristics of a particular flume or weir configuration. If you already have a standard flume or weir on your pipeline the OCF is the best choice, otherwise you will have to consider the cost of installing such a primary device.
The other option is the Area Velocity Meter or AVM that is newer technology and gaining popularity. The AVM has a sensor unit that installs in the pipeline (6″ or larger) and calculates flow by determining the depth and the velocity of the water in the pipe along with the area of the pipe cross-section.
The advantage of the AVM is that no primary device, flume or weir, is required.
There are other pros and cons to each type of flowmeter, so evaluate your system and ask questions before purchasing.
How is an area velocity flowmeter (AVM) different from other flowmeters and where would I use one?
First, an area velocity flowmeter is one of the few flowmeters that will measure flow in a partially filled pipe or channel. This is perfect for gravity flow systems with possible solids in the water.
The AVM can be easily installed in the pipe at a manhole or even at the final discharge point. The AVM works by measuring two parameters: velocity and water depth in the pipe. The combination of these two measurements along with the pipe ID results in a fairly accurate flow measurement.
The AVFM is unique in that an ultrasonic sensor rather than a pressure sensor does the level measurement. It is the pressure-sensing device that has plagued many of the earlier AVM’s offered by other manufacturers.
Can we install my positive displacement meter on a vertical pipe?
Virtually all positive displacement meters require that they be installed on a horizontal plane. Installing these meters horizontally eliminates possible accuracy and excessive wear problems associated with a vertical installation.
If the only pipe available is a vertical pipe, a meter in-setter is often used. There are a variety of pipe connection options available for the different pipe materials, sizes and types often used in household plumbing. Most can accommodate meters up to 1-inch in size.
If you already have a meter installed on a vertical pipe, a vertical to horizontal meter re-setter is often the solution. These devices have meter threads on the vertical portion of the unit to fit in place of the existing meter. They also have meter couplings to install the meter horizontally.
How do we test my remote mechanical register to make sure it is working properly?
The easiest way is test a mechanical remote is with a common 9-volt transistor battery. By removing the wires at the meter and gently brushing the two wires across the terminals of the battery, you are sending an electrical pulse through the wires energizing the remote and advancing the reading.
In addition, you are testing the continuity of the wire as well. If the numerals do not advance, go to the remote and try the same test again attaching two short wires to the terminals on the remote. If the numerals advance, the wire from the meter to the remote will need to be changed and If the numerals do not advance, the remote will need to be changed.
What is the general rule to follow when determining the proper installation location of a flow meter to obtain the greatest accuracy?
For the best accuracy results, the rule to follow is simple. Choose a place in the line to install the meter so that there is ten pipe diameters of straight pipe before (upstream) and five pipe diameters of straight pipe after (downstream) the meter location.
These lengths of pipe provide adequate time for the water to straighten out and pass uniformly through the meter and beyond, eliminating turbulence that may affect accuracy.
How do we determine the meter coupling size I need for my meters?
In the smaller household meters such as 5/8″ x 1/2″ and 5/8″ x 3/4″ sized meters, many manufacturers have 5/8 in the casting of each of the meter sizes, which makes it a little confusing.
The bore is 5/8″, but the diameter of the threads is different between the two meter sizes. By measuring across the meter threads at the meter opening, you can easily determine the proper coupling size.
The diameter of the meter threads of a 5/8″ x 1/2″ meter will be 1″ and they are usually installed on a 1/2″ water service line.
The diameter of the meter threads on a 5/8″ x 3/4″ meter is 1-1/4″, and they are usually installed on a 3/4″ water service line.
We can’t or don’t want to cut my pipe. Which meter type can I use for dirty or wastewater and which meter can I use for drinking water?
With the single sensor mounted on the outside of the pipe, the meter of choice for a dirty or wastewater application is a Doppler meter.
The meter requires solids or bubbles in the liquid with a minimum size of 100 microns and a minimum concentration of 75 parts per million. The Doppler signal is bounced off of these particles to determine flow rate within the pipe.
These meters work well on pipes made of PVC, carbon steel, cast iron, fiberglass and lined pipe. Doppler signals cannot transmit through pipe walls, which contain air pockets like wood or loose pipe liners with an air gap between pipe liner and pipe wall.
For a drinking water quality application, the transit time flow meter is a good choice. They feature two non-intrusive sensors fixed to the pipe at pre-determined spacing based upon pipe diameter and liquid characteristics.
The signal is transmitted between the sensors in the direction of liquid flow and then against the liquid flow. Since sound travels faster with the liquid flow than against it, a time differential is determined. The sound’s time of flight is accurately measured in both directions to calculate the flow rate.
When the time of flight in both directions is the same, the flow meter reads zero flow. These meters work better in cleaner liquids where particulates do not interfere with the signals being transmitted. These meters work on a wide variety of pipe materials.
Reference :
coleparmer.com
flowmeterindia.in
Your blog is really good and it helps others. It's a perfect solution for those who search for it. Please share more information like this. Dexter Magnetic Technologies
ReplyDelete